Getting straight on how russell underestimated frege. Philosophy of language remains indispensable for an understanding of contemporary philosophy. This barcode number lets you verify that youre getting exactly the right version or. Philosophy of language philosophy of language freges revolution. Russell, wittgenstein and quine were all influenced by frege, and much of analytical philosophy can be viewed as building on, or attempting to correct his work. For frege, as for all subsequent analytical philosophers, the philos ophy of language is the foundation of all other philosophy because it is only by the analysis of language that we can analyze thought. The fortysix page introduction and notes to the translations make it useful also for frege scholars. Philosophy of language philosophy of language russells theory of descriptions. No one has figured more prominently in the study of german philosopher gottlob frege than michael dummett. For some time now, historians of philosophy have been gradually coming to terms with the idea that postkantian philosophy in the. The question of the relationship between mind and language is discussed further in chapter 7, when we give a brief, critical account of grices attempt to analyse the notion of linguistic meaning in terms of the notion of intention. Other readers will always be interested in your opinion of the books youve read.
It is easily readable by graduates or advanced under graduates. Gottlob frege was among the first philosophers who placed language at. Philosophy of language has been highly influential. Frege s on sense and reference philosophy of language. He developed both claims while studying the work of the german philosopher and mathematician to whom he devoted so much of his intellectual efforts. Scott soames is distinguished professor of philosophy at the university of southern california, specialising in the philosophy of language and the history of analytic philosophy. Although language has been a matter of concern throughout the history of philosophy. Departing from frege is an outstanding contribution to philosophy oflanguage and logic and will be invaluable to all those interested in frege and the philosophy oflanguage. Freges contribution to philosophy of language oxford handbooks. An introduction to the philosophy of language this book is a critical introduction to the central issues of the. It is true that, in contrast with frege s and russells works, the tractatus is an opaque piece, whose claims and even more, the. This will involve an exploration of, in particular, frege s criticism of lockes psychologism, and frege s view that thought is objective and intrinsically public. Many of philosophy s traditional central puzzles are simply a misunderstanding of language use.
Karen green has done more than write a study of dummett s philosophy of language. Consider, for instance, the hoary problem of nonbeing. Frege and russell were concerned with the semantic as well as syntactic aspect of language. Frege s account is supplanted with the insights of a leading author on the philosophy of language. Review of michael dummett, the interpretation of freges philosophy. The central and largest chapter covers the distinction between sense and reference and includes a defence of the distinction from saul kripkes criticism. This is a huge book dealing with frege s ideas by topic. According to michael dummett, the fundamental principle of analytical philosophy is the priority, in the order of explanation, of language over thought. He was known for his work on truth and meaning and their implications to debates between realism and antirealism, a term he helped to popularize.
Sinn to accommodate difficulties in his early theory of meaning. That text is not an introduction to the ideas of frege for someone who has never heard any of them, or has never heard any discussion of the philosophy of language. In this exciting new collection, a distinguished international group of philosophers contribute new essays on central issues in philosophy of language and logic, in honor of michael dummett, one of the most influential philosophers of the late twentieth century. Dummett, michael internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Informative identities in the begriffsschrift and on sense.
Frege also supposed that when a binary function f i. He wrote on the history of analytic philosophy, notably as an interpreter of frege, and. The philosophy of language with john searle youtube. An introduction to the founder of modern analytic philosophy by anthony kenny daniel slanger added it mar 02, apart from a couple of anthnoy that will make some of the explanations of frege s system difficult for those not already familiar with symbolic systems, this is another excellent effort by anthony kenny. Sir michael anthony eardley dummett fba 19252011 was an english academic described as among the most significant british philosophers of the last century and a leading campaigner for racial tolerance and equality. Many beginning students in philosophy of language find themselves grappling with dense and difficult texts not easily understood by someone new to the field. Texts include classic writings by frege, russell, kripke, quine, davidson, austin, grice, and wittgenstein. Mark sainsburyis susan stebbing professor ofphilosophy at kings college london. Fregean senses, modes of presentation, and concepts.
The oxford handbook of philosophy of language presents the definitive reference work for this diverse and fertile field of philosophy. Philosophy of language as an example, i would suggest the same sorts of things. The philosophy of language is a branch of philosophy which centers on issues involving the nature of meaning, reference, truth. He has published extensively on truth, reference, meaning, the relationship between semantics and pragmatics, and the nature of syntactic and semantic theories of. Philosophy of language michael dummett the philosophy of gottlob frege 18481925 is seen by many as the starting point for the modern analytical movement. Logic and foundations of mathematics in frege s philosophy, vol. This highly acclaimed book is a major contribution to the philosophy of language as well as a systematic interpretation of frege, indisputably the father of analytic philosophy.
Spurred by the rigorization of mathematics in the 19th century, frege set out to show that the truths of mathematics could all be derived from logic, and would not have to. Due to the unclarity of the text, to answer your question, i extrapolate stuff i learned about frege s work in graduate school. But we can in fact say that freges concept script is actually modern predicate logic. Philosophy of language russells theory of descriptions. In othershe considers critically some interpretations of frege, and develops the argument for a sound understanding of frege s thought. Concerning proper names sikander jamil preliminary remarks ottlob frege may be considered as the first intellectual giant in the philosophy of language.
Wittgensteins fundamental insight that the language of logic and mathematics works in a totally different way from the language of empirical statements organizes his tractatus. Frege and the german background to analytic phnosophy 280 gottfried gabriel 8. M suhrkamp, 1988 from grazer philosophische studien, 34 1989, 153173. Time, norms, and structure in nineteenthcentury philosophy of science 250 david hyder 7. Leading international figures in the field contribute more than forty brandnew articles, covering topics from the nature of language to meaning, truth, and reference, and the interfaces of philosophy of language with linguistics syntax, semantics, and. Wittgensteins early philosophy of logic and language. Wittgensteins early philosophy of logic and language, oxford university press, 2006, 316pp. He is author of russell routledge,1985,paradoxes 1995 and. Lecture notes introduction to philosophy of language. In the novel through the lookingglass by lewis carroll, the messenger says he passed nobody on the road, and he is met with the observation. Philosophy of mathematics michael dummett download.
He wrote on the history of analytic philosophy, notably as an interpreter of frege, and made original contributions particularly in the philosophies of mathematics, logic, language and metaphysics. The strengths and weaknesses of freges critique of locke. The continuum companion to the philosophy of language 2 even if the book would not have been possible without frege s and russells groundbreaking research. Dummett, english philosopher who did influential work in the philosophy of language, metaphysics, logic, the philosophy of mathematics, and the history of analytic philosophy. His philosophical reputation is based partly on his studies of the history of analytical philosophy and partly on his own contributions to the philosophical study of logic, language, mathematics and metaphysics. Oxford handbook of philosophy of language oxford handbooks. He was also one of the foremost expositors of the work of the german mathematical logician gottlob frege. Gottlob freges contributions to philosophy of language are so numerous and so fundamental that it is difficult to imagine the field without them. The essay will also show that frege s advances on locke do not go far enough, or at least do not.
Dummett ranked frege among the greatest philosophers of all time. General assessments and historical accounts of frege s philosophy, vol. The essays are focused on areas particularly associated with professor dummett. Introduction to the philosophy of language trnavska univerzita. Buy frege philosophy of language 2e by dummett, michael isbn. But then why wittgenstein is inadequate despite ramsey whispering peircean semiotics in his ear is that rather than this making metaphysics bunk, it is why better metaphysics is demanded. Philosophy of mathematics 1991, it is dummetts chief contribution to frege scholarship. Frege, on the other hand, develops a model where all statements, whether they be empirical, logical, or mathematical, are fashioned on one and the same basic pattern.
Gottlob frege 18481925 is generally credited as the founder of analytic philosophy. In the philosophy of language, the distinction between sense and reference was an innovation of the german philosopher and mathematician gottlob frege in 1892 in his paper on sense and reference. According to locke, ideas exist independently of words, which serve merely as their. He was also one of the foremost expositors of the work of the german. He wrote on the history of analytic philosophy, notably as an interpreter of frege, and made. The second argument is that the structure of our world is determined by the structure of our language. Philosophy of language london, 1973, in the preface to which i acknowledged davidsons general influence on me. This highly acclaimed book is a major contribution to the philosophy of language as well as a systematic interpretation of frege, indisputably the father of. Intuition is not a special source of ineffable insight.
So it should be remembered that when we use the expression rxy or sometimes rx, y to assert that the objects x and y stand in the relation r, frege would say that r maps the. She has in effect written a critical history of the treatment of the theory of meaning by leading figures from frege and wittgenstein on to the present. A fourvolume collection of scholarly articles on all aspects of frege s philosophy, vol. Without wishing to give a definition, i call a thought something for which the question of truth arises. In this work dummett discusses, section by section, frege s masterpiece the foundations of arithmetic and frege. Reviewed by oskari kuusela, academy of finlanduniversity of helsinki. The best books on the philosophy of language five books. Kneale and kneale 1962, 585586, wright 1983, 21, but reworking and extending it not only improves upon dummett s treatment of frege on concepts, it also shows why some traditional difficulties, like the problem of the unity of the proposition, the paradox of predication, and the liar paradox, are not. It is often claimed that natural language is in general compositional, in the sense that the meaning of a complex expression is a function of the meanings of its constituent partsthe principle, which is usually traced back to frege, appeared in the literature in a variety of versions. An introduction to philosophy of language through systematic and accessible explanations of ten classic texts by such thinkers as frege, kripke, russell, and putnam. No one has figured more prominently in the study of the german philosopher gottlob frege than michael dummett. In terms of dummett s other work, using his classic text frege. Dummett, in full sir michael anthony eardley dummett, born june 27, 1925, london, englanddied december 27, 2011, oxford, english philosopher who did influential work in the philosophy of language, metaphysics, logic, the philosophy of mathematics, and the history of analytic philosophy. Theoretical jargon is kept to a minimum and is fully explained whenever it is.
That principle is the thesis concerning the ambiguity of the word is. He was, until 1992, wykeham professor of logic at the university of oxford. Two things must be distinguished in an indicative sentence. Philosophy of language, second edition 2nd edition by michael dummett author 5. One of frege s main semantic principles, is however, missing in dummett s book, frege. John searle and bryan magee discuss the philosophy of language. Michael dummett 19252011 michael dummett was one of the most influential british philosophers of his generation. Philosophy of language, second edition book depository. Wittgenstein, dummett, and antirealism the philosophy forum. In michael thau and ben caplan whats puzzling gottlob frege canadian journal of philosophy 31 2001. In the philosophy of language, the distinction between sense and reference was an innovation or significance, but rendered by frege s translators as reference, referent, meaning, nominatum, etc. Despite locating ideas about language in the writings of plato, we note that heck and may say that frege s contributions to philosophy of language are so. A short introduction to gottlob frege s begriffsschrift the preceding analysis of simple mathematical begriffsschrifft led frege to extend the applicability of this system to the representation of nonmathematical thoughts and predications.
From frege s grand design to davidsons 27 david wiggins 3 intention and convention in the theory of meaning 49 stephen schiffer 4 meaning, use, verification 73 john skorupski postscript. On page 45, frege is in pain to explain the distinction between the sense and denotation of a sentence when it is used in indirect speech. I am not sure whether the fault is in me, in translation, or in frege. The foundations of arithmetic is undoubtedly the best introduction to frege s thought. This book offers an introduction to philosophy of language. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Find materials for this course in the pages linked along the left. The power of frege s logic to dispel philosophical problems was immediately recognized. Frege s most striking contribution to the philosophy of language.
Philosophy of language freges revolution britannica. Freges theorem and foundations for arithmetic stanford. I recommend it for courses on frege, philosophy of language, philosophy of logic, and analytic philosophy. Davidsons earliest relevant essays antedate my first book, frege. Contents notes on contributors introduction analytic. A logicomathematical enquiry into the concept of number. Several of the essays illustrate his contention that frege s work remains the best starting point for the investigation of problems concerning truth, meaning, and thoughtand language, which are still among the. Who is michael dummett referring to in what is a theory of. Also of great influence is michael dummett, frege s distinction between sense and reference, in truth and other enigmas london. Zalta center for the study of language and information stanford university ever since frege postulated senses in 1892 and conceived of them as containing modes of presentation, serious studies in the philosophy of language have often appealed to these entities. The philosophy of language with john searle duration.
990 1500 1351 515 1002 710 660 308 815 1227 762 1405 49 684 1192 1071 455 652 1478 1171 711 888 1443 1110 935 485 1083 1352 192 962 970 981 1528 653 1452 1333 920 78 17 1155 1332 198 1432 913 1298 1011 540